UPTET : Allahabad High Court Double Bench Hearing on 12 Feb Regarding Teachers Recruiment in UP and Stay Extended Till 20th Feb 2012
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
?Court No. - 33
Case :- SPECIAL APPEAL No. - 150 of 2013
Petitioner :- Navin Srivastava And Others
Respondent :- State Of U.P. And Others
Petitioner Counsel :- Abhishek Srivastava,Shashi Nandan
Respondent Counsel :- C.S.C.,Bhanu Pratap Singh,C.B.Yadav
And
1. Special Appeal No. 149 of 2013
2. Special Appeal No. 152 of 2013
3. Special Appeal No. 159 of 2013
4. Special Appeal No. 161 of 2013
5. Special Appeal No. 205 of 2013
6. Special Appeal No. 206 of 2013
7. Special Appeal No. 220 of 2013
Hon'ble Sushil Harkauli,J.
Hon'ble Manoj Misra,J.
������� In this bunch of similar appeals, we have heard learned counsel for the appellants and the learned Additional Advocate General for the State. List these appeals together again as a bunch on 20.02.2013. By that time, a supplementary-counter-affidavit will be filed by the respondents giving full details, and enclosing therewith copies of all the supporting/relevant documents, separately on each of the alleged irregularities referred to in the report of the High Powered Committee.
������ Each of irregularities will be dealt with separately in an analytical manner. During the course of arguments, we have pointed out today to the learned Additional Advocate General that the report of the Committee, which has been enclosed with the counter-affidavit raises the basic question whether the Committee has applied its mind to the allegations and material by way of analytical scrutiny, or has taken too supercficial a view of the matter. By way of an example, the report notes that 3493 carbon copies of OMR Sheets were seized from offices of the Agency conducting the test (TET). A hard disk was also seized and sent to the SFL, Lucknow. Thereafter it says that the SP, Ramabai Nagar has given a report dated 10.04.2012 saying that the investigation so far, has revealed that instead of getting the original OMR Sheets being examined by the Computer, carbon copies of the same had been examined.
������� Merely because the carbon copies were found from the Agency's Office will not necessarily mean that the original OMR Sheets of those carbon copies were not found. This should have been got clarified by the Committee. Further, it has not been considered as to what is the material on the basis of which the S.P. has inferred that the Computer Scanner examined the carbon copies instead of the original Answer Sheets.
������ From the side of the appellants, it has been submitted that the original OMR answer-sheets contain a "Bar Code", without which the Scanner will not examine the OMR sheet. It has been argued, although there is no pleading to that effect, that the carbon copies do not contain the 'bar code', because the carbon copies are to be given back to the candidates after the examination.
������ We are of the opinion that when no opportunity of hearing is being afforded to the concerned selected candidates, and because the decision is likely to alter the fate of more than seventy thousand candidates, a much greater responsibility lay upon the High Powered Committee to elicit full details, to examine and analyse the material so obtained, and to test the reports on the basis of which the Committee is giving its decision.
������� In the above light, a supplementary-counter affidavit should be filed by the State-respondents.
List all these cases on 20.02.2013, as prayed by the learned Addl. Advocate General.
Interim order will continue till the next date of listing.
Order Date :- 12.2.2013
Sunil Kr Tiwari
(Manoj Misra, J.)� (Sushil Harkauli, J.)
**********************************
अभी हाल ही में इलाहबाद हाई कोर्ट ने धांधली आदि के बारे में जानकारी मांगी ।
यह सभी टी ई टी उम्मीदवारों (जिन्होंने मेहनत से परीक्षा उत्तीर्ण की ) के लिये खुशी का पैगाम लेकर आया ।
मेहनती अभ्यर्थी गलत फ़हमी में धांधली की बदनामी से जूझ रहे थे और अगर कोर्ट कह देता है की धांधली नगण्य है या
या हटाई जा सकती है तो ये उत्तर प्रदेश शिक्षा विभाग के लिये भी अच्छी बात है कि उन्हें योग्य टी ई टी उत्तीर्ण अभ्यर्थी अपने विभाग के लिये मिल रहे हैं ।
क्योंकि कम समय में इतनी बड़ी परीक्षा शीघ्रता से कराया जाना बहुत मुश्किल है ।
फ़िलहाल मामला अदालत में है , सरकार और अभ्यर्थी न्यायालय से जल्द फैसले की अपेक्षा में है जिससे सर्व शिक्षा अभियान
शीघ्रता से लागु हो और सरकार की इस कल्याण कारी शिक्षा अभियान से उत्तर प्रदेश के लाखों /करोड़ों बच्चों को मुफ्त शिक्षा मिल सके ।
