Saturday, December 24, 2011

Some UPTET Candidates : TET exam is wrong for Selection of Primary Teacher in UP

टीईटी को लेकर नया बखेड़ा : गुस्साए छात्रों ने किया न्यायालय का रुख
‘परीक्षा को चयन का आधार बनाना गलत’
इलाहाबाद। शिक्षक पात्रता परीक्षा को लेकर नया बखेड़ा खड़ा हो गया है। पात्रता परीक्षा को चयन का आधार बनाए जाने के खिलाफ कई अभ्यर्थी कोर्ट पहुंच गए हैं। अभ्यर्थियों का तर्क है कि देश भर में कहीं भी इस पात्रता परीक्षा की मेरिट को शिक्षक चयन का आधार नहीं बनाया गया।
अभ्यर्थियों ने न्यायालय से अपील की है कि प्रदेश में जिस मजबूरी का हवाला देकर इसे चयन का आधार बनाया गया, वह बाधा भी सरकार ने खत्म कर दी है लिहाजा अब इसकी मेरिट पर चयन नहीं किया जाना चाहिए। इस बारे में एनसीटीई के नियमों, शर्तों का भी हवाला दिया गया है। अगर इस मामले में एनसीटीई के अधिनियमों को आधार बनाया गया तो छात्रों का पक्ष सही साबित होने की पूरी संभावना है और ऐसे में पूरी प्रक्रिया बाधित हो सकती है। टीईटी मेरिट को चयन का आधार बनाने के खिलाफ याचिका ने फिर सांसत में डाल दिया है। अभ्यर्थियों ने एनसीटीई के नियमों के हवाले से ऐसे तर्क रखे हैं जो सरकार को परेशानी में डाल सकते हैं।
अभ्यर्थियों का कहना है कि सरकार ने एनसीटीई की चेतावनी दिखाकर बीएड डिग्रीधारकों को प्राथमिक शिक्षक बनाने के लिए एक समय सीमा तय कर दी थी। प्रचारित किया गया कि 31 दिसंबर तक चयन न किया गया तो बीएड डिग्रीधारक हमेशा के लिए चयन प्रक्रिया से बाहर हो जाएंगे लेकिन एक हफ्ते पहले जारी संशोधन से साफ हो गया कि यह तथ्य गलत था। न्यायालय के निर्देश के बाद सरकार ने जो संशोधन किया, उसमें आवेदन नौ जनवरी तक स्वीकार किए जा रहे हैं।
अभ्यर्थियों ने बात के पक्ष में तर्क रखा है कि तिथि नौ जनवरी तक बढ़ने का आशय है कि 31 दिसंबर की बाध्यता कभी अनिवार्य नहीं थी और यदि तिथि बढ़ सकती थी तो टीईटी मेरिट को चयन का आधार बनाने की मजबूरी नहीं थी।
News : Amar Ujala (24.12.11)
*************************************
As per view of many candidates on this blog/POLL SURVEY BY THIS BLOG/NEWS/ earlier HIGHCOURT DECISONS etc.
Follwing question arises -
Question is - Where NCTE said - TET merit can not be used for selection.NCTE specify - TET pass as a qualification criteria to make Quality in education system.
Why so many BTC candidates failed. Is exam faulty ? If UPTET exam faulty, then who are responsible?
And if proved exam was faulty/very hard etc. them it may be reconducted for TET failure etc.
BTC selection is based on MERIT, But still they are UNABLE to secured minimum passing marks
Why many Vishist BTC candidates not gave this exam. 
This UPTET exam common to all candidates, then what is Unfair.(As per poll survey on this blog -
Most of the candidates, who appeared in UPTET exam, voted - TET merit used for selection.
If NCTE said to maintain quality - TET pass necessary then what's wrong to use TET merit for selection.
Many goverment services selects candidates on different-different methods.It depends on authority - How to select candidates.
I felt -
However, If something wrong happens  in TET exam with some candidates on proper grounds then it should be properly treated may be adjust in new vacancies etc.But lakhs of students who already wait for there selection should not affected. And goverment should effectively implement RTE act for poor childerens as early as possible.

32 comments:

  1. I STRONGLY SUPPORT TO THIS BECAUSE DUE TO LOTS OF THE REVISION IN TET RESULT IT HAS LOST IT VALUE FOR SELECTION CRITERIA AND NOW SELECTION SHOULD BE BASED ON ACADEMIC QUALIFICATION IN WHICH TET PERCENTAGE ALSO SHOULD BE ADDED SO GIVE YOUR VIEWS ALSO..

    ReplyDelete
  2. I STRONGLY SUPPORT TO THIS BECAUSE DUE TO LOTS OF THE REVISION IN TET RESULT IT HAS LOST IT VALUE FOR SELECTION CRITERIA AND NOW SELECTION SHOULD BE BASED ON ACADEMIC QUALIFICATION IN WHICH TET PERCENTAGE ALSO SHOULD BE ADDED SO GIVE YOUR VIEWS ALSO..

    ReplyDelete
  3. AGAR APKO LAGTA HAI K APME TEACHER BAN NE KI YOGYATA HAI TO YOGYATA PARIKSHAN SE KAISA GHABRANA..SELECTION tet merit base par hi hona chahiyeq k har board/university k marks dene ka apna alag criteria hota hai..jaise cbse board me students k % hmesha high rehte hai,so up board k studnt ko aise me loss hoga and baki log jo donation k basis par exam qualify krte hai unke bhi % high rehte hai..

    ReplyDelete
  4. thx 4 supporting me...mujhe ye samajh me nahi aata k jb tet exam se pehle ye declaird kr diya gaya tha k selection tet merit k basis par hoga to log ab q naya issue bana rahe hai??jin logo ne highst marks gain kiye hai kya wo pagal the jo unhone itni mehnat ki..ye objection wahi log kar rahe hai jinke tet me kam marks aaye hai..aur agar shayad jyada aa jate to wo bhi hmara favour krte...sorry mai kisi ko blame nhi kar rahi hu but itna to ap log bhi soch sakte hai kya jo issue ap uthane ja rahe hai wo sahi hai...SOCH SAMAJH KR FAISLA KARIYE..

    ReplyDelete
  5. agr aapko tet k merit ko hi apply krna tha to y kam s km 20 din phle btate ......aur lgatar ho rhe sansodhan k vavjud jis trh galtiyan abhi bhi h ye exam apni pramarikta kho chuka h...

    ReplyDelete
  6. thnx 4 cmmnting bt let tell me one thing k apko problm kis wajah se hai??agar result revisd hua hai to sbko iska profit hua hai ..kisi k marks kam nahi huye hai..ap khud hi soch kr dekh lijiye k paper me kewl basic se ques puchhe gaye the aur students unhe bhi solv ni kr paye to bachho ko wo kya padhayenge bhagwan jaane,...systm to apni galtiyan sudhar lega bt jo hmari kamiyaa hai unhe hume hi sahi krna hoga...

    ReplyDelete
  7. SANDEEP I STRONGLY SUPPORT TO THIS BECAUSE DUE TO LOTS OF THE REVISION IN TET RESULT IT HAS LOST IT VALUE FOR SELECTION CRITERIA AND NOW SELECTION SHOULD BE BASED ON ACADEMIC QUALIFICATION IN WHICH TET PERCENTAGE ALSO SHOULD BE ADDED SO GIVE YOUR VIEWS ALSO..

    ReplyDelete
  8. Ms Neha if u have the capability than I you should have good percentage in all academic qualifications because it TET type of test a if u will give chance to 100 illiterate peoples than out of 100 minimum 10 will pass it because they people also will fill up the round circle or definitively 100 me se 10 ka TUKKA to lag hi jayega understood.

    ReplyDelete
  9. dont be angry sir...it was jst my opinion okkkkk..
    and if u read my previous cmnnt dn i think u didnt ask me such type of ques..mere ya apke kehne se decisn nahi liya jayega..jo right hoga ussi ka favour hoga dts all.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Yes Neha very true dont mind it I was giving my opinion and you also know some where it happens ok so let the govt. decide and as per my perception selection should be based on this criteria that is - % of TET+%of 10th + % of12th+% of gradu.+B.Ed. now give your opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  11. neha ji me phle apne bare m btata hu mere tet m 101 h sience se hu may be k mera h jaye y nhi bt wo nhi h na mere acedemic m jyada h evrg 60 ka ayega bt jo shi h wh hr jgh shi hota h..me kisi k khne pr apni opinion change nhi krta aur jahn tk apne gud teaching k bt khi mene b.ed m apne cleg m 2nd rank payi h with 72prcnt to kya me ek accha tchr nhi bn skta

    ReplyDelete
  12. mai manta hu ki tet result me itne sasodhan k bad yeh 80 pesent hi fair reh gaya hai fir bhi mai neha ji se sahmat hu kyoki up board and cbse board etc me no. dene ka system alag alag hai. Self centre me logo ne khub nakal ki jisse unki merit high ban rahi hai.
    TET ko merit ka adhar na banaya jai yeh appeal karne walo se mai puchana chata hu ki abhi tak so rahe the? ya yeh intzar kr rahe the ki tet ka result dekh le tab yadi no. na mile to court me tet ko chayan ka adhar banane ko chalenge karege. Pl'z aisa kuch na kare ki kisi ka bhi chayan na ho.

    ReplyDelete
  13. so nah rhe the,lekin ab iski koi value nah rha gaye hai kyonki ye bahut baar revised ho chuka hai. don know kiske kitne marks badha diye gaye hain,na answer key di hai aur na hi ye bataya h ki kis que me marks diye hain ,kisi ke 2 badh gaye hai to kisi k c 4,aur kisi ke to 1 bhi nahin badhe,kya apko ye lagta hai ki ab is pe trust kiya ja sakta hai,haan jab 2nd dec ko revised result declared ho gaya tha uske baad tak tet merit pe selection sahi tha,bt ab hmre acc sahi nain hai,aur vaise bhi hm logo ke bahes krne se kya fayda,hoga wahi jo govt. ne or director of bsa ne decide kr rkha hai.So ab 9 jan k baad dkehiye kya hota hai,

    ReplyDelete
  14. KYA AACHAR SIHINTA LAGU HONE SE VACANCY PER ROK LG JAYEGI YA PRIKRIYA CHALTI RHEGI PLZ RPLY ANYBODY..

    ReplyDelete
  15. nhi rok nhi lgegi kyuki process phle s shuru h ......

    ReplyDelete
  16. In my opinion gov. should give weight-age to both TET score and and candidate's academic performance but in a different manner. They should prepare merit as:

    10% of high school %age + 20% of intermediate %age + 40% of graduation %age + 40 % of B.Ed. theory %age + 20 % of B.Ed. practical % + marks obtained in TET.

    I think this selection criterion would be fair enough and would suit to every one. This selection criterion was used in the PRT vacancy for the UTTARAKHAND state.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Yes dear very rite this is a proper criteria for selection ...

    ReplyDelete
  18. maine pahle bhi kaha hai ki jo log tet ki merit ka virodh ker rahe hai wo nakal ke mare hain.dus-dus hajar me 90% leker bethe hain.bhai unka bhi khyal karo jo 2000 se pahle b.ed. ker chuke hain.kya karan hai ki 1999 me b.ed. walo ko primary teacher merit ke adhar per banane ke bad, bad ke varshon me bed me 70% ana mamuli bat ho gaye jabaki isse pahle b.ed. me mostly second div hi ati thi.saf bat hai ki up ka education system nakal mafiyayon ke hath me chala gaya. is govt ne bahut accha badlav lane ka prayash kiya hai to in samaj virodhi tatwo ke pet me dard ho raha hai.san 1993 se 10 and 12 ka result ap dekh sakte ho. pahle 30-35% result rahta tha. 1992 me nakal adhyadesh lagu hone ke bad rusult 14% gaya tha uske bad agli sal result 80% iska kya karan tha? tab se leker ab tak up ka education system sudhar nahe paya.

    Ab govt ne tet merit ke adhar per selection karke education system me "upper cut" lagaya hai to yah apne pradesh ke liys acchi bat hai. Sabhi govt jobs me selection written exam ke bad hi hota hai. (ye log un jobs me bhi merit se selection kyo nahe le lete)

    AB sudhaar ke prakriya shuru ho gaye hai.

    Ye baat NCTE,Central Govt,Court ke bhi sangyan me hai.

    In logo ke halat Amerika jaise ho gaye hai(jisne laden ko badhava diya tha phir wahi unka jani dushman ho gaya) aise hi ye log bhi us system ke mare hue hai jis system ko in logo ne khada kiya tha. Yadi us samay dhyan laga ker padh liye hote to yahi log kahte bhai tet merit ke adhar per selection hona chahiye.

    Sabse acche bat yah hai ki Govt ne Exam saf suthara kara liya hai.Nakal mafiya ke chal nahe paye . Answer key me galat ans feed ho gaye to un galtiyo ko dur ker liya gaya hai aur kya bacche ki jan loge.

    kash Ye mera comment nyaypalika ke pas bhi pahunch jaye.

    Hope UP BADAL RAHA HAI.

    SATISH

    ReplyDelete
  19. tet exam ko chayan ka adhar banana isliye sahi hai kyonki ap dekh sakte hain ki 421 logo ke marksheet fargi paye gaye hain.

    ReplyDelete
  20. maine pahle bhi kaha hai ki jo log tet ki merit ka virodh ker rahe hai wo nakal ke mare hain.dus-dus hajar me 90% leker bethe hain.bhai unka bhi khyal karo jo 2000 se pahle b.ed. ker chuke hain.kya karan hai ki 1999 me b.ed. walo ko primary teacher merit ke adhar per banane ke bad, bad ke varshon me bed me 70% ana mamuli bat ho gaye jabaki isse pahle b.ed. me mostly second div hi ati thi.saf bat hai ki up ka education system nakal mafiyayon ke hath me chala gaya. is govt ne bahut accha badlav lane ka prayash kiya hai to in samaj virodhi tatwo ke pet me dard ho raha hai.san 1993 se 10 and 12 ka result ap dekh sakte ho. pahle 30-35% result rahta tha. 1992 me nakal adhyadesh lagu hone ke bad rusult 14% gaya tha uske bad agli sal result 80% iska kya karan tha? tab se leker ab tak up ka education system sudhar nahe paya.

    Ab govt ne tet merit ke adhar per selection karke education system me "upper cut" lagaya hai to yah apne pradesh ke liys acchi bat hai. Sabhi govt jobs me selection written exam ke bad hi hota hai. (ye log un jobs me bhi merit se selection kyo nahe le lete)

    AB sudhaar ke prakriya shuru ho gaye hai.

    Ye baat NCTE,Central Govt,Court ke bhi sangyan me hai.

    In logo ke halat Amerika jaise ho gaye hai(jisne laden ko badhava diya tha phir wahi unka hani dushman ho gaya) aise hi ye log bhi us system ke mare hue hai jis system ko in logo ne khade kiya tha. Yadi us samay dhyan laga ker padh liye hote to yahi log kahte bhai tet merit ke adhar per selection hona chahiye.

    Sabse acche bat yah hai ki Govt ne Exam saf suthara kara liya hai.Nakal mafiya ke chal nahe paye . Answer key me galat ans feed ho gaye to un galtiyo ko dur ker liya gaya hai aur kya bacche ki jan loge.

    kash Ye mera comment nyaypalika ke pas bhi pahunch jaye.

    Hope UP BADAL RAHA HAI.

    SATISH

    ReplyDelete
  21. dear mr.satish i am strongly agreed with your views .this is really a good move by the government. ALL THE BEST!

    ReplyDelete
  22. when first time result was declared every one knows that he got right marks (approximately) except those ques which were wrong or whose answer was mistakenly placed in the answer key. The entire body behind the exam has good motive otherwise not only question paper but also carbon copy of answer sheet should not be provided for the students. so if somebody who says that the exam has lost its value is totally wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  23. satish i agree with u. kuch log hote hi hai virous. na to apne kucch karenge na dusaron ko kucch karne denge.
    naveen

    ReplyDelete
  24. KOI BTA SKTA H KI MERIT KAISE BANEGI...RPLY PLZ...

    ReplyDelete
  25. mujhe lgta h ki kuch logo ne gdbd krke tet m acche marks bnwa liye h so jyada bhaag rhe h....ha ha ha

    ReplyDelete
  26. MERIT KA ABHI BHI KUCH NAHI KAHA JA SAKTA KI KISPRAKAR BANEGI LEKIN EK BAAT TO NISCHIT HE KI YADI TET KO ADHAR BANAYA GAYA TO 90% CANDIDATE TEACHAR KE PATRA HONGE,10% HO SAKTA HE KI SAM DAM DAND BHED SE PASS HUE HO.OR YADHI MERIT 10TH SE TET KO LEKAR BANAI GAI TO ISME I THINK 50%-70% AISE CANDIDATE HONGE JINHONE JUGAD SE APNI % BANAI HO.OR 30-40% AISE HONGE JO REAL ME TEACHER YOGYA HONGE.MAI KISHI KE PACHH ME NAHI BOL RAHI YE AAP SAB JANTE HO OR JANKAR BHI MAN NAHI RAHE HO.AGAR MAI APNI RAY DO TO TET KO HI ADHAR BANANA CHAHIYE KUE KI AGAR AISA NAHI HUA TO UN LOGO KI SHIKSHA VIYARTHA JAEGI JINHONE BASATAB ME MEHANAT KI OR UN LOGO KE BALLE BALLE HO JAEGI JO NISCHIT RUP SE BHARAT KE BHAVISYA KO KHARAB KAR DENGE.I HOPE GOVN.WILL DO BETTER

    ReplyDelete
  27. KUCH LOG KAH RAHE HE KI TET LOST ITS VALUE KYON KI BAR BAR SANSODHAN JO HUE HE TO JANAB BATAIYE SANSODHAN PARTICULAR KISI EK KE RESULT ME TO NAHI HUE BO TO LAGBHAG SABHI KE RESULT ME HUE HE JHA TAK HER PHER KI BAAT HE TO 1-5% LOG TO LAGBHAG SABHI GOVN.DEPARTMENT ME JUGAD SE LAGTE HI HE.BO ALAG BAAT HE KI YE ISSUE KABHI DISCLOUSE NAHI HOTE.OR CURRENT TET ME HOGAE HE MERA TO BAS SABHI SE YAHI KAHANA HE KI MERIT KAISE BHI BANE HAME USE SWEEKAR KARNA CHAHIYA.NA KI TANG ADANA.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Tet k aadhar pr hi merit bne mai aisi prarthna krti hu..tanishka

    ReplyDelete

To All,
Please do not use abusive languages in Anger.
Write your comment Wisely, So that other Visitors/Readers can take it Seriously.
Thanks.