Upper Primary Teacher Recruitment UP/ Allahabad Highcourt : Writ Regarding Quality Points in Upper Primary Teacher Selection
UPTET / टीईटी / TET - Teacher Eligibility Test Updates /
Teacher Recruitment News
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
?Court No. - 1
Case :- WRIT - A No. - 51486 of 2013
Petitioner :- Alok Kumar Yadav And 2 Ors.
Respondent :- State Of U.P.& 5 Ors.
Counsel for Petitioner :- Alok Kumar Yadav
Counsel for Respondent :- C.S.C.,B.P.Singh,Deo Dayal,R.A.Akhtar
Hon'ble V.K. Shukla,J.
Learned Standing Counsel has accepted notice on behalf of the respondent no.1 and Sri B.P. Singh, Advocate has accepted notice on behalf of the respondent nos. 2 to 5. and Sri R.A. Akhtar, Advocate has accepted notice on behalf of the respondent no.6.
Each one of the respondent is granted six weeks time to file counter affidavit. Rejoinder affidavit may be filed within two weeks thereafter.
List on 11.11.2013.
In the present case, petitioners are assailing the validity of Rule in question to the effect and extent, it proceeds to award marks in lieu of training qualification. Petitioners' submission is that under Appendix-12 of Rule 14 (3) of U.P. Basic Education Teacher (Service) Rules,1981, in lieu of Ist, IInd and IIIrd Division, in theory and practical different set of marks has been provided for i.e. in case incumbent has passed his B.Ed Examination in Ist Division, then he is entitled for 12 marks in theory and 12 marks in Practical. In case incumbent has passed his B.Ed Examination in IInd Division, then he is entitled for 6 marks in theory and 6 marks in Practical and� similarly if incumbent has passed his B.Ed Examination in IIIrd Division, then he is entitled for 3 marks in theory and 3 marks in Practical. Petitioners' submission is that in the State of U.P. there are various Universities established and in the said University in question, different parameters have been provided for awarding marks in Ist, IInd and IIIrd Division. Petitioners submission is that oince� Universities have fixed different parameter for awarding in Ist, IInd and IIIrd Division, then candidates who have pursued their course from the Universities, wherein higher percentage� has been� provided for higher division, would be� in disadvantageous situation. Petitioners have tried to� demonstrate before this Court, the parameters� fixed� by different Universities for awarding division in paragraph 10.
In view of this, petitioners submit that said criteria� on the face of it is arbitrary and unreasonable� and criteria has been provided to compute marks in lieu of academic qualification� ought to have been adhered for bringing the� candidates on common equal pedestal.
Prima facie looking into the arguments advanced all the respondents are directed to file counter affidavit within one month. Rejoinder affidavit may be filed within two weeks. It is made clear that selection and appointment be� made,� but same shall abide by final order to be passed by this Court.
Order Date :- 20.9.2013
T.S.
Source : http://elegalix.allahabadhighcourt.in/elegalix/WebShowJudgment.do?judgmentID=2812371
**********************
If anybody/ visitor have better knowledge regarding this writ / related matter then he can provide his information thorough comments.
Ab ye bhartiyan ho ya na ho par inka kisi bhi tarah ka chunavi labh govt. Ko nai hone wala. Go to hell sp...
ReplyDeleteKya koi bateyga ki Up junior science and math teachers bharti ki Tet ki merit par hone ke liye court main koi writ dali gayi hai kya agar koi writ nahi dali gayi to padni chahiye kyonki b.ed.ke 3 6 12 no ka sytem bilkul galat hai
DeleteKin mahan logo n dali ye writ 72825 se sbk nhi liya
ReplyDeleteKya koi bateyga ki Up junior science and math teachers bharti ki Tet ki merit par hone ke liye court main koi writ dali gayi hai kya agar koi writ nahi dali gayi to padni chahiye kyonki b.ed.ke 3 6 12 no ka sytem bilkul galat hai
DeleteYe writ dalne wale logo ka is bhrti se koi lena dena to h nhi gov k hi bnde h bs stay k liya kiya h ye sb up ka ab kuch nhi ho skta
ReplyDeleteAb to kuch kahne sunnne ka bhi man nai karta. Jungule raaj hai yahan!
ReplyDeleteAb cm k aur basic k putale fuke jayenge,aur koi chara nahi hai.
ReplyDeleteHum unemployment walon ka paisa khaker gov kabhi chunav nahi jitegi.Hum sabhi logo message denge ki koi bhi candidate sp gov ko na de.
ReplyDeleteMaine 60 district se chalan bhara tha aur junior me 30 dist. ab overage hone wala hoo.
their is also another writ regarding B Pharm candidate who is not considered as eligible candidate for science teacher recruitment athough all other professional degree holders are eligible.counter affidavit allready asked from govt.link is
ReplyDeletehttp://elegalix.allahabadhighcourt.in/elegalix/StartWebSearch.do
This news is also published in Gorakhpur dainik jagran news 19/10/19 page no 6
Editor ji nd bhaiyo abi jo u.p me 10000 prt ki bharti nikali h usme b.ed. Walo ko kyu nhi liya ja rha h jb b.ed. Walo ne ctet2011 nd uptet 2011 diya hua h for primary teacher jiski validity 5year tk h to uneh u.p. Ki primary teachers ki bhartiyo me kyu nhi liya ja rha ha jbki centr gov. Ne b parmisn di hui h k b.ed. Wale primary teacher bnege march 2014 tk to sirf btc nd vbtc urdu walo ko kyu liya ja rha b.ed. Walo k sath partiality kyu ho rhi h kya b.ed. Walo k liy ak hi bharti(72 hjar) hi thi agr yhi thi to uptet2011 nd ctet2011 k cirtificae pe likha kyu nhi k ye sirf ak hi bharti k liy h kyu uski validity 5year rakhi hui h aare bhai bharti to bharti hi h prt ki fr usme jo chahe aply kre btc ya vbtc ya urdu to b.ed. Walo k sath kyu partiality ki ja rhi h jbki uneh parmisn b h nd tet b pas h unka to kya problm h u.p gov. Ko bhai...nd centr gov. Ne kya parmisn jhak marne ko di hui h ya sirf dikhane k liy di hui h Editor ji plz tell me vrna ak rit direct supreme cort me dali ja skti h Qk high cort to kuch krta nhi h nd ak ak aplicasn Pardhan mantri, Rastpati,Rajypal,Mukhyamantri, Abitabh agnihotri nd other ko bheji ja skti h koi to hoga jo sunega.
ReplyDeleteYe writ karne wale sarkar ke hi aadmi hai. Sarkar nahi chahati ki ye bharti ho.
ReplyDeleteYe btc m bed wale writ dal de we are also eligibl for this vac so bed walo writ dalo 10000 btc m
ReplyDeleteSp gov hum logo ko bewakuf bana rahi hai. 2014 election ko dekhate huye ye gov lagatar vacancies nikal rahi hai taki adhik se adhik vote batora ja sake aur dusari taraf apne chamcho se writ pe writ dalawa rahi hai taki ek tir se tin sikar kiya ja sake... 1-primary&junior candidate ke paiso se laptop bat sake. 2-janata (prm &jnr candidate) khush hokar khub vote de.3-court ke bahane bharti bhi na karani pade.but..dear akhilesh ji ye public hai sab janti hai.agar ye vacancy ho bhi jati hai tab bhi ap ko koi candidate vote nahi karega.
ReplyDelete